The 7 Best Wild-Caught Seafood Delivery Services 2024

Wondering where to buy top-quality fish and other seafood online? To help you out, I have rounded-up the best sustainable and wild-caught seafood delivery services. You can order everything from the comfort of your own home and it gets delivered straight to your doorstep. Special deals and discounts are also included!

The Best Wild-Caught Seafood Delivery Service

I picked ButcherBox as the best wild-caught seafood delivery service in 2024. It is a terrific option for most people, because it offers unparalleled quality, value, and reliability. ButcherBox offers a great selection of healthy meat, fish, and other seafood. They provide excellent customer service as well. In my opinion, their meat and/or seafood subscription is well worth the cost.

If you’re interested in learning more about ButcherBox, you can read through my review of it below and then browse through their user-friendly website. I’ve also included details about the other six fish and seafood delivery companies I recommend below.

Why You Should Buy Wild Seafood Online

I am a big believer in consuming wild-caught seafood instead of farmed seafood. Wild fish and other seafood is so much more healthy, flavorful, and sustainable than the conventional variety. However, finding high-quality and sustainably-sourced seafood isn’t always easy. Even if you do have access to a reliable seafood market or grocery store seafood department, there is a good chance you are always short on time. That means staying on top of household tasks, like grocery shopping, can be very challenging.

Fortunately, there are a number of online retailers that can deliver wild seafood to your home, for less than you might think. These online-order delivery companies offer fish and seafood such as salmon, whitefish, shrimp, lobster, crab, and more. The seafood is expertly packaged and then gets delivered right to your door as a one-time order or recurring subscription. Keep reading to learn more about my top choices, along with some exclusive discounts!

Pictured: Easy Grilled Salmon

1. Wild-Caught Seafood Delivery: ButcherBox

ButcherBox is an incredible meat and seafood delivery service that sends premium cuts straight to your front door. Their seafood selection includes wild-caught and sustainably-harvested Alaskan sockeye salmon, halibut, cod, lobster, sea scallops, and shrimp. Their meat selection includes 100% grass-fed beef, heritage-breed pork, and free-range organic chicken.

ButcherBox has partnered with fishermen who uphold strict fishing and handling practices. This guarantees an unprecedented level of quality and sustainability. All of their seafood contains absolutely no artificial coloring, additives, hormones, or antibiotics.

The individual selections of meat and/or seafood arrive frozen and vacuum-packed in an insulated box. You can order a custom box, where you get to pick the exact items that you want. Or, you may order a curated box, where ButcherBox pre-selects a special mix of cuts for you. The price per meal is under $6 and shipping is free to the continental 48 states.

You can pause your delivery or cancel your membership any time before your next billing date, with no hidden fees or penalties. If you’re not completely satisfied with your order, ButcherBox will either send you a replacement, offer you credit towards your next delivery, or give you a refund.

Click here to get an amazing offer from ButcherBox when you sign up!

Pictured: Marinated Tuna Kebabs

2. Sustainable Seafood Delivery: Good Chop

Good Chop delivers top-quality American meat and seafood to your doorstep. All of their meat and seafood is sustainably-sourced from domestic family farms and fisheries. Their cuts contain no artificial ingredients, added hormones, growth stimulants, antibiotics, or preservatives.

Good Chop sells fish and seafood that is wild-caught off U.S. coasts or responsibly-raised in U.S. farms. You can choose from wild-caught Alaskan salmon, rockfish, sea scallops, Pacific cod and coldwater shrimp. Just like the rest of their meats, their seafood is completely free of any antibiotics, additives, or coloring.

Overfishing is a serious threat to our oceans. For that reason, the company only partners with responsible fisheries that carry the blue Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) label. The MSC is a global nonprofit organization that works to end overfishing around the world. It ensures that stocks are fished in a way that does not threaten the population’s long-term health. Additionally, it minimizes the damaging effects of fishing to the surrounding wildlife and ecosystem.

Aside from their wild-caught selection, Good Chop also offers sustainably-farmed fish that is approved by the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC). The ASC promotes sustainable farming techniques. This includes testing water quality, responsibly sourcing feed, preventing disease, and promoting animal welfare. 

You can customize each box you receive with delicious cuts of seafood, chicken, pork, and/or beef. You may pause or cancel your delivery at any time. Lastly, if you’re not 100% satisfied with your order, they will either credit your account or issue a refund.

Click here to get $100 off your first three boxes when you join Good Chop!

Pictured: Broiled Lobster Tails

3. Wild-Caught Seafood Delivery: Thrive Market

Thrive Market is an online retailer that sells healthy, organic food at wholesale prices. I like to think of it like Amazon (online retailer) meets Costco (wholesale prices) meets Whole Foods (all wholesome, junk-free foods).

The company sells both wild-caught and responsibly-farmed seafood. Their fish and seafood collection features Alaskan sockeye salmon, ahi tuna, cod, barramundi, shrimp, scallops, lobster tails, and more. Thrive Market only works with ethical partners that support marine habitats with humane fishing practices. Their seafood is packed and frozen shortly after catch, to preserve that fresh-off-the-boat taste.

Thrive Market’s seafood delivery options include several bundled fish and seafood boxes. You can select single-fish boxes, like the Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon Box. Or you can order variety boxes, like the Wild & Sustainable Seafood Box, which contains wild scallops, sockeye salmon, barramundi, and more. You can also customize your own meat and seafood box, if you prefer to pick and choose items.

To order any type of seafood or groceries from Thrive Market, simply sign up for a Thrive Market membership. You can cancel your membership at any time, so it is completely risk-free. If you use the link below, you will get this fantastic limited-time bonus when you join:

Click here to get a $60 free gift when you purchase a Thrive Market membership!

Pictured: Baked Honey Mustard Fish

4. Wild Fish Delivery: Farm Foods Market

Farm Foods Market is an online vendor that features grass-fed meats, pasture-raised chicken, heritage pork, and wild seafood. All of their seafood is sustainable and wild-caught by small-scale family fishermen. The company does not sell any farmed fish.

Their fish and seafood is completely free of any chemicals, antibiotics, hormones, GMOs, artificial colorings, and preservatives. Their seafood choices include wild-caught Alaskan sockeye salmon, Alaskan halibut, Pacific cod, swordfish, and New Zealand greenshell mussels.

You can browse through their user-friendly website to see what kinds of seafood and/or meat you would like to purchase. You may also read about each different farm/fishery they source their meat and seafood from, to learn more their practices.

All of their meat and seafood cuts are vacuum-sealed and delivered to you in a reusable Styrofoam cooler. The meat and seafood is kept frozen using enough dry ice for it to last more than 12 hours after delivery. That way, it’s not a problem if you’re not at home when it arrives. In addition, you will get free shipping on all orders over $125. Lastly, if your package gets delayed and/or arrives in a poor condition, they will refund your money.

Click here to get 10% off your first order at Farm Foods Market with the code EATS10!

Pictured: Singapore Chilli Crab

5. Sustainable Fish Delivery: Sizzlefish

Sizzlefish delivers all-natural fish and shellfish directly to your doorstep. They offer a broad range of seafood including salmon, cod, rockfish, shrimp, calamari, soft-shell crab, sea scallops, clams, and more. They work closely with their suppliers to source only the finest sustainable seafood. Most of their seafood is wild-caught, although their Atlantic salmon, rainbow trout, and catfish are farmed.

The seafood is carefully packed in a reusable, recyclable cooler containing plenty of dry ice. Each box contains 14 vacuum-sealed, perfectly-portioned cuts of seafood. Your seafood should arrive hard-frozen, so all you need to do is transfer the items into your freezer.

You can order a hand-curated seafood box à la carte or sign up for a subscription. Their subscription service allows you to build your own seafood box, or let Sizzlefish choose the items in your box for you. Lastly, if you’re not completely satisfied with the quality of your seafood, they will replace your products free of charge.

Click here to get free shipping on orders over $100 at Sizzlefish!

Pictured: Mango Chipotle Fish Tacos

6. Sustainable Seafood Delivery: Fulton Fish Market

Fulton Fish Market began as a physical fish market in New York City. It has grown to become the second largest fish market in the world (after Tokyo). They now have an online store, which makes it easy for anyone in the contiguous United States to access one of the biggest assortments of fresh seafood anywhere.

The company offers both wild-caught and farmed seafood. Every product page on their website clearly specifies if the seafood is wild or farmed in the product description. In addition, their seafood sources are reviewed daily for sustainability.

You can purchase almost any variety of fish from salmon to swordfish, halibut, and a few harder-to-find species. Additionally, the company sells a wide range of shellfish including oysters, lobsters, soft shell crabs, mussels, scallops and clams.

Their seafood boxes contain a thermal-insulated liner and food-safe, frozen gel packs to keep your seafood cold when it arrives. You can order fish à la carte by the piece, box, or curated bundle. You can also start a subscription to get a monthly, bimonthly, or weekly curated box of fish regularly delivered to your front door.

Click here to check out Fulton Fish Market!

Pictured: Thai Shrimp Noodle Soup

7. Wild-Caught Seafood Delivery: Vital Choice

Vital Choice is an online purveyor that sells wild-caught and sustainably-harvested seafood. If you struggle to find premium seafood at your grocery store, this delivery service is a good alternative.

Vital Choice’s seafood options include flash-frozen Alaskan salmon and halibut, Chilean sea bass, ahi tuna, and more. In addition, they sell live shellfish, such as Pacific blue mussels, clams, and oysters. They have an assortment of canned and pouched seafood available for purchase as well. Additionally, the company offers an array of marine supplements such as omega-3 capsules, salmon and cod liver oils, and daily immune support packets.

The owners and executive staff at Vital Choice have decades of experience as professional fishermen. Their seafood is certified sustainable either by the MSC, the State of Alaska, or Monterey Bay Aquarium’s SeafoodWatch program.

You can make a one-time order of any of their products. You can also sign up for a monthly seafood subscription box, which contains a pre-selected mix of fish and shellfish. Finally, if you’re not satisfied with your purchase, the company will either replace your product or refund your money.

Click here to try out Vital Choice for yourself!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Here are some common questions (with answers!) that you may have about buying wild-caught fish and using seafood delivery services:

Why should you eat wild-caught fish?

While eating fish is generally good for you, getting wild-caught fish instead of farmed fish is worthwhile. By choosing wild-caught fish, you can ensure that you’re not consuming harmful contaminants or antibiotics. Wild-caught fish is also lower in saturated fats and contains higher amounts of several vitamins and minerals than farmed fish (source).

Can you buy wild and sustainable seafood at the grocery store?

Yes, you can buy wild and sustainably-sourced seafood at the grocery store or farmer’s market. However, top-quality fish, shellfish, and other seafood can be difficult to find. Unless you have a reliable local source that you can trust, it can be easier to purchase wild and sustainably-harvested seafood online.

Are seafood delivery and subscription services worth it?

It depends on how much fish, shellfish, and other seafood you and your household consume each month. If you regularly eat seafood during the week, then the companies such as the ones listed above may actually help save you money and cut down on trips to the grocery store.

With a delivery service, you can’t physically see the seafood items before making a purchase, the way you can at a grocery store. So, this can discourage some people from signing up with a seafood delivery company. However, many delivery companies offer a discounted first order, which makes it a low-risk way to try a service out. After you receive your first order, you can see if the seafood is what you’re looking for and if the company is something you would like to continue using.

The majority of the seafood from the companies in this article arrives frozen, so it will last a long time in the freezer. If you really like using a seafood subscription and want to use one long-term, I recommend investing in a standalone freezer to keep in your basement or garage. Usually, when you purchase food in larger quantities, you get more bang for your buck. And if you find that you have more seafood than you need on hand, you can just skip or cancel your subscription altogether.

Best Wild-Caught Seafood Delivery: Final Thoughts

To summarize, high-quality fish and other seafood can be hard to find. However, there are impressive seafood delivery services available. You just have to do a bit of research to learn about what is out there. Then, you can get started with a delivery company that suits your household needs and budget.

I selected ButcherBox as my top choice for sustainable and wild-caught seafood delivery. I love everything about the company, and I truly believe you will not be disappointed with it. All of the other services in this article also offer great value, so they are good options as well.

More At-Home Delivery Services

If you would like to learn about other healthy at-home delivery companies, check out these helpful articles:

• Top 7 Grass-Fed & Organic Meat Delivery Services
• The Best Organic Wine Delivery Companies Online
• Butcher Box Review: Is Butcher Box Worth it?
• 7 Best Organic, Healthy Grocery Delivery Services
• The Best Online Smoothie Delivery Companies
• Top 5 Healthy Food Subscription Boxes Online

Have you tried any of these online services for sustainable and wild-caught seafood delivery? Let me know in the comments below!

This article was originally published on May 16, 2020. It has been updated throughout to include new delivery services, helpful information, and exclusive offers.